Armed with this evidence and 3C signals, we spent most of March, all of April and May 1st putting together and filling out our core short positions, of which we had 9 and by the June 2012 lows, all 9 were at double digit profits from our entries in Q1 as the market turned down virtually the same time the seasonal adjustment period ended.
Last week we already saw signs of even the headline numbers turning down, amidst the height of the seasonal adjustment period. While not exactly a seasonal adjustment, last week's Initial Claims looked pretty good until one realized that not only were 3 states including the most populous in the nation, California, all estimated (due to the holiday shortened week), but beyond that there were more people dropping off extended benefits than the Initial Claims, meaning the data was deeply skewed without context and misunderstood. This week's revised reading for last week (which is virtually guaranteed as it happens about 95% of the time) will almost certainly be worse, but that will only give the mainstream financial media the opportunity to contrast this week's number vs. a worse revised reading from last week (as we have seen the media do time after time for whatever agenda they are pushing-it is not unbiased analysis though), allowing them to make the claim that there's improvement in the current reading vs last week's number as no one cares about last week's revised number which is buried far from the headlines other than the current weak beat the negatively revised number.
Still, the point is that the macro economic data is deteriorating badly and much earlier than last year which saw the market fall as soon as we went from seasonally adjusted to the normal readings with no arbitrary adjustment, leaving many with no chair when the music stopped. This poor data is what we are seeing now, despite what the general conventional thinking is, look at the 4 consecutive F_E_D manufacturing readings, all worse, many hitting multi-year lows and all showing contraction in US manufacturing. If one goes on to read the details, the sub-indexes also show many individual components deteriorating, interestingly one of the big ones is the employment index which is deteriorating-although this is a different way to read unemployment (through F_E_D manufacturing surveys rather than BLS data). I doubt very much that this trend underway is temporary noise, thus I don't expect improvement.
If you follow some data, but not all, this may sound confusing as a rosy picture is being painted in the US and Europe, but if you dig in to the details and compare actual reports vs confidence indicators which are arbitrary, you'll see there's a deep divide between what is being sold and what can actually be observed.
This week's AAII (American Association of Individual Investors) sentiment survey hit a startling new bull/bear spread. Historical data has shown that when the spread of bullish respondents has at least an +18 point spread above bearish sentiment responses, we are at a bearish reversal point-18 points being a fairly healthy spread, not anywhere near the average. Take a look at this week's AAII investor sentiment report which is a great reverse indicator when at extreme levels (18 point spread being defined as extreme which has shown real moves in the market)...
The long term average spread is 8.5 points, this week jumped over 11.5 points to a spread of 28!
"Right Side Of TheChart" took the time to take the historical data from AAI's website and superimpose bullish spreads of +18 or more on the SPX and bearish spreads of 18 or less (the first depicting bearish reversals and the second depicting bullish reversals) and here's what it looked like.
For the thoughtful, it's obvious that dumb money and smart money can't be on the same side of the boat and expect smart money to make profits, they need someone to trade against in a zero-sum game, but for those experienced in market behavior from years of careful observation, the reason is more insidious, it all comes back to the head fake move and the reasons for them. With the SPX breaking above the psychological level of $1500 (as a magnet and as a sub-consious centennial number-think about shopping and prices at $14.99 rather than $15.00) the reason is more often than not, the setting of bull or bear traps which act as accelerators to reversal moves with little to no cash outlay on smart money's side one the trap is set. Think about this for a moment, the 2002-2003 bull market start to the 2007 top took 5 years, to erase all of those gains and then some it took about 16 months with most of the damage coming in 8 months, part of the reasons is fear is stronger than greed, but another part is the setting of bull traps that create fast losses and fast moves to the downside as additional losses multiply exponentially- the market crossing $1500 brings in a lot of dumb money. You can read more about this in the first two installments of the 3 part series, "Understanding the Head-Fake Move"
Part 1
Part 2
The truly scary thing about SPX $1500 is the change in price vs the change in the real economy. The 2002-2007 bull market was fueled by consumer spending which was fueled by rising property values and the HELOC. Looking at the market today vs even the top in 2007, we were in a much better economic position at the top, even though it was painfully obvious there was a bubble about to burst in a big way, but the jobs, the manufacturing, the global economy were all still there and intact, that's the difference now, which may be the reasons "Trend #2" looks so bad in comparison to trend #1 which is stronger than we anticipated just as I predicted, what does that tell us of trend #2?
In any case, Here's the open of the FX market tonight...
This is the breakout from the triangle in the EUR/USd we have been talking about over the last week or two, I said it wouldn't be a clean cut affair, it looks that way now, but it won't for long, this is just the nature of the markets and especially when we are near a very narrow area of very important support and resistance as we are at the apex of a triangle like this, the move to take out support doesn't have to be as big when the apex is so narrow. I do suspect this to be a head fake move in the EUR/USD, it's also a move I have been expecting and I don't think its importance is nearly fully realized yet.
I first became concerned with the two parabolic moves up in the Euro, after that there was no follow through, this was a warning, then Goldman coming out with a long EUR/USd call for the general public as the last 3 major calls they have made have all gone the other way, not because they are wrong in their analysis, but because they are using the call to accomplish a goal, if you are a buyer of the EUR/USD don't be surprised if you are buying from GS.
This is what Technical Analysis expects from the price pattern in the EUR/USD, this is what they have received, this is also the easiest way to set a bull trap because dumb money using technical analysis is already expecting this to happen so they will buy it with little hesitation, again see the two part article linked above, specifically part 1 in this instance.
Here's the opening of trade for the FX pair for the week ...
The breakout and then support at the triangle not only confirms this is what technical traders are looking at, but it has done everything TA says it should, the thing is TA has been used against technical traders for the last 10 years with increasing frequency.
And the long term daily view of the trend in the EUR/USD which reflects the problems in the EU which have not been solved.
In fact, the re-payment of LTRO loans in greater amounts than expected may indeed start to send sovereign yields up creating a new panic in the EU as early as this week.
This is what ES looked like about an hour ago, it's really not doing much presently and is a few points below Friday's 4 pm close, I don't read much in to this right now as there are few major markets open like bonds, etc.
ES has deteriorated a bit since the capture, as I said I wouldn't read much in to it.
Last week we saw deterioration in to the major averages in the important timeframes, not only long term/big picture, but longer timeframes short term which is worse for the smaller picture or immediate future.
I did see some very short term positive signals and that' why there were some short term long treads offered up late last week, but I expect these to be very short, possibly even closed out tomorrow. I still feel there's a very high probability that the reversal starts with what looks like a very strong day and quickly turns to a very negative day, this being the actual start of a reversal. One thing you may want to watch carefully for would be signs of the market trend vs the TICK indications, if the market trend is positive and the TICK data on a 1 min chart diverges negatively from the market, this is a major red flag, but I suspect we'll have many other signals first.
Some of you sent emails this weekend and I need to finish several of them, I wanted you to know that I do have them, I will respond to them.
As always, if anything changes tonight in futures, I'll let you know, but I don't expect any changes until pre-market or possibly around 3 a.m.
If you took any of last week's long trades, please keep up with the updates on those trades, they were all entered with the idea of them being very short term, but perhaps very profitable which is in line with the intraday/fast reversal I've suspected.