Sunday, January 15, 2012

Europe is killing their own bond market

First let me say from an American perspective traveling to Europe, there is certainly a noticeable difference in attitudes and policy. In many ways, the European model looks socialist, 6 weeks of vacation is the norm throughout many countries in Europe. I have friends in Germany that left their 12 year jobs with American Airlines based in Frankfurt, they will collect their normal paychecks from AA for two years even though they are no longer employed, they still have the benefits of flying for next to nothing and are receiving 66% of their former salary in their form of unemployment compensation. In reality, they are making more money unemployed then they were employed and retain many of the perks.

While many in the US would say we have our own socialist institutions, the attitudes and scope of the differences clearly make Europe look quite a bit more socialist. It may be this general attitude in Europe in dealing with the sovereign debt crisis that is actually exacerbating it.

There are certainly issues concerning the Greek debt restructuring that will effect the entire EU bond market. The ECB, which is the largest holder of Greek debt seems bent on not taking any losses in the restructuring. Draghi avoided the direct question twice as to whether the ECB is prepared to take losses on their Greek debt holdings and the vice chief emphasized that the restructuring was "PSI", Private Sector Involvement, hinting that the ECB would not be a party to any restructuring deal as they don't consider themselves to be "private holders" even though the debt they bought was clearly issued as private debt.

This raises the issue of the equality of treatment of creditors and any exclusion of ECB debt would have to be done by inserting specific procedures excluding the ECB in retroactive collective action clauses which would effect ALL Greek law bonds. This would shred the principle of comparability of treatment between creditors in the event of sovereign debt restructuring which has been a principle respected since its inception in 1956. 


In reality, this tells bond investors that should another country require debt restructuring, their haircuts on the debt will be proportionately larger depending on how much of that specific debt the ECB holds. The more sovereign debt the ECB holds, the bigger the haircuts for private investors. This would discourage any bond buyer from buying sovereign debt in the EU, the exact opposite of what the EU most desperately needs and may explain why China and Japan have stayed at arms distance.


The Sovereign Downgrades
This week's downgrades are not a mere rating, these ratings are used to guide investment by all kinds of funds that may be and in many cases are barred from holding or buying debt that is not of a particular credit worthiness. This means the S&P rating action will likely FORCE many investment institutions to sell debt that is no longer rated within their guidelines that govern their investments. What I'm saying is it is not a matter of choice, they have rules in place that must be followed and may force them to sell debt holdings to comply.


This is where Germany's CDU ruling coalition/ Merkel may have just dropped the bomb that kills the bond market.


At the bottom of this FT article is the one paragraph that could kill the EU bond market.

"Speaking on the fringes of a start-of-year retreat of her Christian Union lawmakers in the city of Kiel, Ms Merkel said she would consider calls from her party colleagues for legislation to bar institutional investors such as insurance companies from being forced by their statutes to sell bonds when ratings were downgraded, or fell below investment grade."



Although the US made somewhat comparable remarks regarding how downgraded US debt should be viewed, it was not canonized in to law. This also is where we see the socialist mentality of the EU and how at almost every turn it has run afoul of democratic free market principles and thus has been very ineffective.


Whether the CDU pursues legislation or not, the mere hint of it may send debt holders scrambling to sell their debt before they are potentially caught in a trap that would cause major legal problems for them. If they start selling en masse, yields will rise quickly which will cause the ECB to buy more debt on the secondary market, which in turn will comeback to what was mentioned above about bond holder haircut severity being a function of how much debt the ECB holds, should Greece insert provisions excluding the ECB from retroactive collective action clauses. 


Do you see the circle and the potential of a massive downward spiral? 


Following this to its logical conclusion, yields on debt rise throughout the EU which in turn puts more countries in danger of default and in need of bailout cash that is just not there.


When I first started seeing these obvious horrendous decisions parties in the EU were making, I thought, "This is too obvious, I must not understand the bigger picture", but as the results have played out, I did understand and none of these horrendous decisions were hard to understand. Almost every summit has been a failure and has looked like there has been no communication whatsoever between the various players, I believe it's not only appearance, but fact.


In the end, it probably boils down to a simple problem at the heart of it all, the Euro-zone was a bad idea from the start and never had the structure or the imagination to put in place effective policy tools to deal with anything but a rosy economy.


While the SKEW index is new and unproven at this point (it is meant to signal the likelihood of a Black Swan event), I can't help but noticing it's recent moves higher (the higher the index, the more likely a Black Swan event will occur-115 is the average and represents a low probability of a Black Swan event).


 Current SKEW Index

 SKEW vs the SPX (there have been several price declines of up to 16% or so on higher SKEW readings.

The recent Rate of Change (white) shows a fairly dramatic change since the start of 2012.







Friday, January 13, 2012

Full S&P Downgrade

As you know France was stripped of their AAa status and downgraded 1 notch. This has obvious implications for the credit status of the EFSF bailout mechanism with the burden put squarely on Germany.


As somewhat expected, Cyprus, Italy, Portugal and Spain were cut by two notches.


Austria, Slovakia, Slovenia and Malta all received 1 notch downgrades (along with France).


The S&P said their actions were "primarily driven by insufficient policy measures by EU leaders to fully address systemic stresses".


All in all 9 of the 15 countries under review were cut. There has been a little political mud-slinging since the action. While some have expressed anger at the S&P accusing them of playing politics, others such as Germany' s Michael Fuchs, deputy leader of Merkel's CDU party said, 


"This step is out of order. Standard and Poor's must stop playing politics. Why doesn't it act on the highly indebted United States or highly indebted Britain?"


"If the agency downgrades France, it should also downgrade Britain in order to be consistent."


I would just point out to Mr. Fuchs, the S&P cut the US AAa rating a while ago.



SPY After Hours

3C which is used on ES harts, was originally developed to look at after hours trade in the SPY. So here's  look at what happened in to the close and in AH.

The negative divergence to the left was after hours Thursday night, the fall that came right after that was pre-market Friday morning. There was one positive divergence in regular hours today in white, since then the late afternoon bounce and after hours action have been in a leading negative divergence. Considering the S&P AH release, the divergence in to higher prices makes perfect sense to me.

US Treasuries, China and Europe.

Bloomberg's BusinessWeek says:

China’s Forex Reserves Drop for First Quarter Since 1998


I and others have been talking about the European (more specifically the Euro-zone) banks selling everything not nailed down to raise their capital levels. This has been very obvious since at least October when we saw for the first time ever Markit's PrimeX 4 major averages (these are prime mortgages, not subprime and consider to be of some quality) all trade below par. The take away? EU banks were selling everything and that included $US dollar denominated assets which they then sold (the $US dollars) and bought Euros so they could repatriate the capital. In October this caused an algo legacy arbitrage rally as the Euro gained because of demand and the dollar fell because of supply, which sent the market up as the algos misinterpreted what was happening as bullish, as the $US was down, stocks looked cheap and the computers were buying. 

We then saw other markets hit, specifically the F_E_D's custody account saw US Treasuries being sold en masse. The latest disclosure from the F_E_D this week shows a new all time record outflow of treasuries, $85 billion and counting as this is now 6 consecutive weeks of sales. 

I have speculated that this has not only been in assets that are easy to track such as the F_E_D's foreign custody account, but probably US equities as well including hedge fund redemptions.

Where is the money going? Just look at the ECB deposit facility which has seen all time new highs this week in deposits that yield .75%. At this point, since the December 23rd ECB Long Term Repo Operation in which they offered 1% 3 year loans, there have been more deposits in to the ECB's deposit facility then capital taken by banks at the LTRO, meaning all of the LTRO cash and then some has been placed in the custody account for a loss of .25%. 

In other words, the only lending going on between banks is facilitated by the ECB as no one trusts the counter-party banks. This is the same liquidity freeze seen during the 2008 sub-prime mortgage crisis. At this point, the only thing I can see that would get money out of the ECB and back in to the financial system would be the ECB cutting the deposit interest rate from the current .75%, but as Draghi stated this week, there has been no discussion of lowering the deposit interest.

My gut feeling is that the sovereigns, such as France/Sarkozy in particular who predicted the LTRO cash would be used in a carry trade in which the LTRO money is used to buy high yielding sovereign debt , is the goal of the sovereigns. As a banker, I think the ECB's Draghi understands that the banks primary goal is to raise cash and my gut feeling is that he agrees with that position and will likely not do anything to stop the current trend because when the financial system implodes (Greece's breakdown in talks re: debt restructuring could easily be the catalyst as they have a massive turnover of debt in March and may not get the next tranche of aid from the Troika in time, producing a disorderly default) the banks will be best served holding cash, not toxic bonds.

What all of this means for the US and debt issuance in the near future is another story and one that could be the least under appreciated ticking time bomb in the US markets.

Widely anticipated, but now official, France cut to AA+

As Per Forbes

S&P Downgrades France To AA+, Maintains Negative Outlook


The negative outlook means that the S&P may cut France again

Why The Greeks May Be Spending Bailout Cash on Weapons

You may remember my post this week about the Greek government entering in to contracts to buy everything from tank ammunition, to submarines, frigates, patrol boats and Apache helicopters.

From Reuters:

Greece euro exit worse than catastrophic -Toscafund

A Greek exit from the euro zone would be worse than catastrophic and could provoke greater social unrest, Zimbabwe-style inflation and a military coup, said London-based hedge fund firm Toscafund.

In a stark note to clients, chief economist Savvas Savouri said introducing a new currency instantaneously in the wake of a euro exit would be impossible and the delay would lead to "a run on banks and evacuation of capital that would make what has already been seen as nothing by comparison".
"The word catastrophic would not do it justice enough," said Savouri, who comes from a Greek Cypriot background.
"Those who imagine some post-euro-exit stability would be restored ... quite simply fail to understand the magnitude -- social, economic and political -- of such an eventuality."
He predicted a range of problems for the country, from hyperinflation, extreme difficulty for the government in raising money on bond markets and an evacuation of people able to leave the country, taking as much wealth as they can with them.
"Inflation in Greece would quite frankly spiral in a way resembling Zimbabwe's experience," said Savouri, who also predicted severe poverty amongst the elderly.
"The social unrest seen up until now in Greece would be nothing compared with what would be seen in the dawn of a new drachma."
"It would not be hyperbole to argue that the denouement of a Greek exit from the euro would be at worst the rise of poisonous political extremists and at best a military coup."

As a teaser, in 2008 the inflation rate hit 231,150,888.87% 

Now that ES is closed, watch for the S&P announement

XLK/Technology

These charts probably should have been included in the AAPL post.

 This is the 15 min XLK chart, followed by the 30 and 60 min. Not only are they all in a deep leading negative divergence, there's good confirmation as to when the divergences really started, pretty much at the end of December/ early January.

 XLK 30 min

XLK 60 min

Interestingly, because MoneyStream rarely gives strong intraday signals. Also note the timing.
 XLK MS 15 min

 XLK MS 30 min

XLK MS 60 min

AAPL follow up

Here we have a VERY wedgie (bearish) price pattern, there was a breakout from the wedge which would appear to be a headfake move. The day in yellow set a all time new intraday high on about 45% more volume then the 22 day average (I used a shorter average volume because volume has been falling and it is more in tune with recent volume action). AAPL could not hold that new high and closed below the all time closing high as of that day; that would indicate some churning was going on that day. Of course there was no follow through and as I have stated several times, AAPL looks like it's been pushed up on a short squeeze, which means there wouldn't be any underlying institutional support for prices at this level.

 The 1 min hart has generally shown confirmation up and down, it's actually a bit leading negative when comparing relative price levels.

 The same is true of the 2 min chart, I've marked the leading component in red here.

 15 min goes from upside confirmation to a sharp negative divergence at the new high attempt, even with the recent 3C bump, it's still in a leading negative position.

The hourly chart is quite clear.

The daily 3C chart above and the daily MoneyStream chart below need no explanation.

Possible SPY Trade

 If we can get a gap fill soon, I may consider some SPY Puts.

The longer term price action (bearish wedge) with a probable false breakout (white box) with a leading negative divergence in place, looks like this may be a major turning point.